‘If football is shut down we know where the fault lies’ Experts want action on Covid rule-breakers

Virologists, public health doctors and epidemiologists are queuing up to urge football’s governing bodies to crack down on Covid rule-breakers who celebrate goals in tight-knit huddles.

The experts claim the players are setting a bad example to the nation and risking the a disastrous shut down in the national game. 

Government has warned ‘the optics’ of players breaching social distancing rules coupled with a rampaging virus and high infections rates make it harder to justify the continuation of elite sport. 

And now a series of urgent meetings have been set up between the Premier League, captains and managers to address the new Covid protocols – amid fears that continued non-compliance may trigger government intervention.

Paul Pogba was mobbed by Manchester United team mates when he scored a goal at Burnley

Paul Pogba was mobbed by Manchester United team mates when he scored a goal at Burnley

Manchester City players break Covid rules by hugging while celebrating against Brighton

Manchester City players break Covid rules by hugging while celebrating against Brighton

The latest expert to speak out is microbiologist Professor Paul Hunter, who was dismayed to see players hugging in celebration, after the Premier League had issued tough new guidance telling them to avoid just that only days before.

Team mates from Everton, Wolves, Sheffield United and Manchester United all before enjoyed exuberant and intimate celebrations after netting crucial goals on Tuesday.

And on Wednesday, those scenes were repeated with Manchester City and Fulham players forming huddles after crucial strikes. 

And Hunter, a Professor of Medicine at the University of East Anglia, joined other leading academics in telling Sportsmail players are taking unnecessary risks with their own health by forming a celebratory scrum after goals.

Sheffield United players embraced after scoring in their first win of the season

Sheffield United players embraced after scoring in their first win of the season

‘That’s how this thing spreads – inhaling breath and saliva that comes out of other people’s mouths,’ said Hunter. ‘And if everyone is yelling while they do that it increases the risk.

‘Most of the air breathed in will be exhaled by other players. Group hugs should not be tolerated. There are all sorts of things players could do to celebrate.

‘Personally, I think it is important for football and sports to continue. It helps a lot of people get through. But it has to be done on a way that is safe and does not encourage unsafe behaviours in others. These sorts of behaviours are dangerous if they do influence others to think footballers can get away with it.

Everton's players enjoyed an exuberant celebration after scoring in their win away to Wolves

Everton’s players enjoyed an exuberant celebration after scoring in their win away to Wolves

‘It has to change.’

Football’s governing bodies have come under pressure from government to eradicate the breaches of social distancing rules on and off the pitch after a series of high-profile incidents.

Ministers are concerned the flagrant abuse of social distancing by footballers will cause a souring of the public mood and force them into a position where they feel compelled to shutdown elite sport.

The Premier League still wants to leave it to the clubs to sanction players who break the rules, but Hunter believes firm action is needed to change behaviour.

Wolves' players had a celebratory scrum when they equalised in their match against Everton

Wolves’ players had a celebratory scrum when they equalised in their match against Everton

‘I agree that in the grand scheme of things, football is not going to be driving this pandemic,’ he told Sportsmail. ‘But a number of footballers have made it clear in the last few months that they do not think the rules apply to them. They think they are above the law

‘If football does not get its act together over this it will be stopped almost certainly, to the detriment of British society.

‘There is no excuse for high-risk behaviour just because you are a footballer. The rules are there for everyone and apply for everyone. If football is shut down because of this we know where the fault lies. That is something that should not have needed to happen if clubs and the [football authorities] took this seriously.’

Shutting down sport was considered as part of Boris Johnson's latest lockdown

Culture secretary Oliver Dowden has warned English football's leaders over the game's issues

Shutting down sport was considered as part of Boris Johnson’s latest lockdown – and culture secretary Oliver Dowden has warned football’s leaders over the game’s issues

The Premier League’s new protocols, issued on Friday, include avoiding ‘unnecessary contact at all times’ including ‘handshakes and hugging’, as well as instructions to wear face masks on the bench, spot checks of dressing rooms and team buses to ensure social distancing measures are being followed.

HOW PREMIER LEAGUE STARS BROKE RULES 

Tottenham’s Sergio Reguilon, Erik Lamela and Giovani Lo Celso were fined and reminded of their responsibilities after they were pictured in a large group photo alongside West Ham’s Manuel Lanzini and their families on Christmas Day.

Manchester City say they are investigating after Benjamin Mendy held a New Year’s Eve party which included guests from outside his household. He was a substitute in City’s next game.

Crystal Palace and Fulham launches investigations into Aleksandar Mitrovic and Luka Milivojevic after they were pictured partying together – but Palace fielded the midfielder as captain in their next game.

Advertisement

The Premier League says that the clubs should investigate and sanction ‘individual transgressions by relevant persons’.

Its guidance adds: ‘Failure to do so may result in disciplinary action by the league individually against the relevant person, where appropriate, and/or against the club.’

But the league says the rules do not support on-field punishment for ignoring social distancing and they don’t say what sanctions it will impose if clubs fail to act.

Two managers, United’s Ole Gunnar Solskjaer and Sheffield United’s Chris Wilder defended their players’ actions.

Solskjaer said: ‘It is difficult when you score because you want to celebrate with your teammates. We will try our best to follow the guidelines, but it is difficult.’

And Wilder said: ‘It is an emotional game on the pitch and on the touchline… it is unnatural and unreal (not to celebrate).’

The Premier League transgressions come after the FA Cup third round ties at the weekend when teams almost universally engaged in group hugs and Chorley and Crawley Town celebrated with a singsong and champagne, respectively, in the dressing room.

And this comes after breaches of Covid rules by seven Premier League players form five clubs during the festive period, when they attended parties in breach

Government sources have told Sportsmail that there is ‘growing frustration’ among ministers who don’t want to see footballers breaking the rules in their private life or  hugging on the pitch. 

Three Spurs stars and a West Ham player (identified above) broke rules to party despite Covid-19 restrictions being in place over the Christmas period

Three Spurs stars and a West Ham player (identified above) broke rules to party despite Covid-19 restrictions being in place over the Christmas period

Troy Deeney (pictured) wants Boris Johnson to halt football amid rising Covid numbers

Professor Paul Hunter is concerned about celebratory scrums after goals in elite football

Troy Deeney (left) has called on Prime Minister Boris Johnson to shut down football, while Professor Paul Hunter wants the sport to continue, but players to observe Covid rules

Professor Hunter is the latest in a line of experts to speak out on Covid and football. Dr Julian Tang at the University of Leicester, Professor Keith Neal from the University of Nottingham and Dr Gabriel Scally, visiting Professor at the University of Bristol have all expressed their concerns to Sportsmail.

Dr Tang advocates reviewing the competition rules in the Premier League, EFL and FA Cup to introduce yellow cards where players don’t distance.

‘Why take the risk to yourself or your contacts from a single 10 or 20 second scrum,’ he said. ‘You don’t have to do it.

‘If it happens once you get a yellow card and if it happens again you are off. It is a disincentive for that contact, recognising that it could have much bigger consequences.’

Crawley Town also celebrated in their remarkable win over Leeds United in the FA Cup

Crawley Town also celebrated in their remarkable win over Leeds United in the FA Cup 

On Tuesday, Jonathan Van-Tam, England’s deputy chief medical officer, has said that footballers should socially distance after scoring a goal.  

Meanwhile, Troy Deeney has called on Prime Minister Boris Johnson to call a halt to football.

‘Unless the government or governing bodies step in and say, “you cannot do this, you cannot do that”, then it goes back to what’s morally right,’ Deeney told talkSPORT.

‘You can’t stop people from going away [on holiday], you can’t stop people from playing football and naturally going to hug your team-mate who assisted you – it’s something we’ve done for years.’ 

PREMIER LEAGUE COVID-19 TEST RESULTS FOR 2020-21 SEASON 

Round 1: Aug 31-Sep 6 – 1,605 tested, with three testing positive.

Round 2: Sep 7-13 – 2,131 tested, with four testing positive.

Round 3: Sep 14-20- 1,574 tested, with three testing positive.

Round 4: Sep 21-27 – 1,595 tested, with 10 testing positive.

Round 5: Sep 28-Oct 4 – 1,587 tested, with nine testing positive.

Round 6: Oct 5-11 – 1,128 tested, with five testing positive.

Round 7: Oct 12-18 – 1,575 tested, with eight testing positive.

Round 8: Oct 19-25 – 1,609 tested, with two testing positive.

Round 9: Oct 26-Nov 1 – 1,446 tested, with four testing positive.

Round 10: Nov 2-8 – 1,646 tested, with four testing positive.

Round 11: Nov 9-15 – 1,207 tested, with 16 testing positive.

Round 12: Nov 16-22 – 1,530 tested, with eight testing positive.

Round 13: Nov 23-29 – 1,381 tested, with 10 testing positive.

Round 14: Nov 30-Dec 6 – 1,483 tested, with 14 testing positive.

Round 15: Dec 7-13 – 1,549 tested, with six testing positive.

Round 16: Dec 14-20 – 1,569 tested, with seven testing positive 

Round 17: Dec 21-27 – 1,479 tested, with 18 testing positive 

Round 18: Dec 28-Jan 3 – 2,295 tested, with 40 testing positive 

Round 19: Jan 4-Jan 10 – 2,593 tested, with 36 testing positive

Advertisement
Sports