Carly And Nina’s Forever Feud

Carly first became involved in Nina’s life when she saw Nina’s daughter, Nelle Hayes (Chloe Lanier), die from a fall off of a cliff. Carly connected the dots that Nelle was Nina’s long-lost daughter, but she kept the secret to herself. When the truth eventually came out, Nina turned her anger on Carly for keeping the secret about Nelle’s cause of death and her parentage. That was the start of what would become a years-long grudge match between the two women.

When Sonny was presumed dead after a fall into a river during a fight, he was found alive but with no memory of his life before. He was hired at a bar owned by Phyllis Caufield’s (Joyce Guy) husband, Lenny Caulfield (Rif Hutton). Calling himself Mike, Sonny was soon discovered by Nina, who realized his situation but kept it to herself. She flirted with Sonny and even kissed him before returning to Port Charles. When Nina tried to tell Carly about Sonny being alive, she immediately changed her mind when Carly went off on Nina for her relationship with their shared grandson, Wiley Cooper-Jones. Her decision didn’t come without consequences.